Dragon Stories
-- An Annotated List
FOREWORD
While deciding on the theme for the annotated bibliography I was to compile
for a one-week advanced storytelling seminar course at Palmer School of
Library and Information Science, I sought suggestions from my supervisor,
Ms. Angeline Moscatt. Ms. Moscatt suggested that I work on a list of
Chinese dragon stories.
This sounded as good as any other idea I had at the time. After
looking at some basic collections of dragon stories, both Chinese and
not, another idea bubbled up to the surface. Never a dragon fanatic, I
had only vague ideas as to what dragons were all about. To me, Chinese
dragons had always been more symbolic with deeply embedded social
significance than characters in stories. Dragons from the Western
tradition had simply been fanciful creatures that one encountered
occasionally in folk tales and children's books. Curious as to the
similarities and differences between Western and Eastern dragons, I
expanded the bibliography to include both sorts. Since I am a
children's librarian and have read many modern children's books
featuring dragons, I began to wonder which dragon traits have
survived through the thousands of years of their existence and which have
disappeared when entering the realm of children's literature. I extended
the bibliography again to include modern children's book dragons.
After a little more than a month's gathering of materials, reading, and
thinking about dragons, I have come to some realizations:
- Western Dragons have existed in the Bible, myths, and
ancient tales, disproving my naive assumption that they were invented
by writers of the Knights/dragonslayer tales.
- If there are not "dragons" from every land in the world, serpent like
monsters/gods definitely can be found in almost all cultures. It is
often difficult to decide whether a certain creature is a dragon. This
difficulty is evidenced in the fact that one of the two versions of the same
story calls its monster a dragon and the other version names the monster
a serpent.
- Traditional Western Dragons tend to be viewed as witless creatures
whose pure intention is to destroy. They are simply beasts who do not
command any means to communicate with humans. Most of the traditional
western dragons are put in stories firstly to symbolize the evil of the
world -- greed, gluttony, destruction, etc., and secondly to be conquered
by heroes. They are both symbols and devices for storytelling.
- Traditional Chinese dragons are very different in temperament and in
what they symbolize. They have been the symbol of power and good fortune
for thousands of years in Chinese culture. In stories, even though
they are often portrayed as bad-tempered and extremely powerful, they are
acknowledged as akin to humans. They usually have human forms and speak
human languages, are sometimes humans to start with, and are almost
always associated with some natural elements that are important to an
agricultural society -- most frequently, water and weather.
- Western dragons in contemporary children's books, especially in
picture books, have ceased to be a symbol of pure evil, or even truly
threatening
adversaries. The portrayal of these dragons ranges from benign to utterly
plush and cute. An opinion essay discussing the shared characteristics
in contemporary children's picture book dragons entitled "Scare Them Off or Be Friends With Them: Picture Book
Dragons" is being drafted at this moment.
This annotated list is far from finished at this point and might never
be. My intention is not to choose a good telling over a lesser one,
but to present as many stories as I can find so that the readers can spot
similarities and differences from one telling to another, and from one
type of dragon story to another.
|